Brendon Villegas and Rachel Reilly‘s adventure-themed baby shower was perfectly fitting for the Big Brother and Amazing Race alums.
The couple, who are expecting their first child together this spring, prepared for the exciting arrival of “#BrenchelBaby” with a “magical” family- and friend-filled shower at their California home on Saturday. At the shower, the pair revealed that they are expecting a daughter.
Villegas, 35, and Reilly, 31, tell PEOPLE they let their guests get crafty at the party.
“We had them help make an ABC book for the baby girl,” Reilly says. “We had a craft table where they could make baby tutus, baby barefoot sandals and baby headbands and decorate onesies.”