Stephanie Izard Welcomes Son Ernie William

05/26/2016 at 04:15 PM ET

Stephanie Izard Welcomes Son Ernie William
Courtesy Stephanie Izard

A future Top Chef hopeful has arrived!

Stephanie Izard and her husband Gary Valentine welcomed their first child, son Ernie William Valentine, on Thursday, May 26, her rep tells PEOPLE exclusively.

Born at 6:29 a.m. in Chicago, Ernie weighed in at 8 lbs., 1 oz. and measured 21 inches long.

“Ernie has his dad’s blue eyes and my nose, so he’s a nice little mix of both of us,” Izard, 37, tells PEOPLE. “And then he peed on the nurse … ”

The Top Chef season 4 winner and Valentine, a craft-beer consultant, confirmed the news of their first child’s upcoming arrival exclusively to PEOPLE in February. The big news caught them “a little by surprise,” Izard said, since they’d just started trying to become parents.

“I’m pretty sure I screamed [Valentine’s] name while holding the pregnancy test in my hand with a little disbelief,” she shared.

Want all the latest pregnancy and birth announcements, plus celebrity mom blogs? Click here to get those and more in the PEOPLE Babies newsletter.

Stephanie Izard Welcomes Son Ernie William
Courtesy Valentine Family

And though the couple obviously eventually came to an agreement on a name for the newest little MLB fan (Dad’s a huge Chicago Cubs supporter!), the process wasn’t easy. In fact, Izard said choosing a name was “one of the hardest parts” of her pregnancy, and that they went back and forth on quite a few names that were primarily “old-school traditional.”

“I feel like I’m just excited to meet him and see what he looks like,” the owner of Chicago-based eatery Girl and the Goat told PEOPLE following her pregnancy announcement. “Hopefully, he likes to read like my husband does, and has his blue eyes. But also hoping he likes to eat mushrooms and tomatoes and cheese, unlike my husband!”

— Jen Juneau with reporting by Sarah Michaud

Share this story:

Your reaction:

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

Showing 3 comments

KT on

ADORABLE. Congratulations!!

cds on

He’s got that tough little boy look — he’s adorable!

A Cardinals Fan on

Poor kid’s in for a lifetime of disappointment if he ends up a Cubs fan like his daddy🙂