Ali Fedotowsky and Catherine Giudici Lowe Compete for Title of ‘Cutest Pregnant Person Ever’

05/13/2016 at 12:06 PM ET

Two Bachelor babies are on the way!

In the June issue of Fit Pregnancy and Baby, good friends Ali Fedotowsky and Catherine Giudici Lowe, who competed on separate seasons of the reality series and are both due in early July, open up about their vastly different pregnancies.

Fedotowsky reveals that she and fiancé Kevin Manno were actively trying to get pregnant.

“After two months of trying, I had a chemical pregnancy, which was a huge disappointment. Afterward, I just wanted a baby so badly — nothing about that time was romantic,” she says. “When I finally got a positive result, I jumped around the house, listening to Justin Bieber‘s ‘Baby.’ ”

Catherine Giudici Ali Fedotowsky pregnant Fit Pregnancy
Cheyenne Ellis

Giudici, however, wasn’t expecting to get pregnant. In fact, she only found out when she took a pregnancy test on a whim and husband Sean Lowe peeked at the results.

“He said, ‘Baby, it’s negative,’ and I was like, ‘Yeah, I thought so.’ Then he said, ‘And by negative, I mean positive,’ ” Giudici, 30, remembers. “Then we both looked at each other and had no idea what to do or say. Finally, I said, ‘Want to watch TV?’ ”

She adds: “Inside, I was thinking, ‘Oh, crap, we’ve got to be adults now.’ ”

Catherine Giudici Ali Fedotowsky pregnant Fit Pregnancy
Cheyenne Ellis

Want all the latest pregnancy and birth announcements, plus celebrity mom blogs? Click here to get those and more in the PEOPLE Babies newsletter.

Both women have also experienced pregnancy completely differently.

“I’ve been tired, and I was so nauseated during my first trimester that I lost eight pounds,” Fedotowsky, 31, reveals. “I only ate rice toast, bagels with cream cheese and clementines.”

Giudici’s pregnancy, however, has been smooth sailing from the start.

“I’ve been really blessed to have no symptoms,” she says. “I forget all the time that I’m pregnant, except for the fact that there’s a belly in my way.”

Catherine Giudici Ali Fedotowsky pregnant Fit Pregnancy
Cheyenne Ellis

The reality stars are even split on how prepared they are for motherhood.

“I’m ready to have a baby, but I’m also aware that I have no idea what that entails,” Fedotowsky says. “Whenever I have a holy-crap moment, Kevin calms me down. He says, ‘We’re so ready. I want the baby here today.’ ”

For Giudici, “there’s not one ounce of me that’s ready. We haven’t done a single thing to prepare for the fact that we’re bringing a new human into our house and lives. Instead, we’re relishing our time together and doing whatever we want while we still can, like taking naps and bingeing on Netflix.”

Catherine Giudici Ali Fedotowsky pregnant Fit Pregnancy
Cheyenne Ellis

And although both women can agree on how fun it was to be photographed together for the magazine, each claims the other is the more adorable mom-to-be.

“Ali’s carrying so much cuter than me,” Giudice says. “She’s taller than me.”

To which Fedotowsky replies: “Catherine, you’re nuts. You’re the cutest pregnant person ever.”

— Andrea Park

Share this story:

Your reaction:

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

Showing 6 comments

Em on

Wow, are these children really going to be moms? The one sounds okay, but the other one sounds more excited about Netflix and being in a magazine than being a parent. They need to quit having their “holy crap” moments and start facing reality.

Smithy on

I don’t give a hoot about either of these women, but they are masterful at holding onto their 15 minutes….especially Catherine and Sean. They could teach the others a thing or two.

Good luck to the babies. And good luck to any of Catherine’s followers who are about to be inundated by cutesy quips more than ever before.

Sara on

Catherine is so cute!!

Anonymous on

Smithy, if you hate Sean and Catherine so much why do you even bother to read any articles about them?

Brielle on

Nothing’s wrong with Catherine’s answers! at least she’s being honest. not sure why even read the article if y’all hate them so much.

XL on

Love Catherine, she is cute!

From Our Partners

Sign up for our daily newsletter and other special offers.
    Choose your newsletters
Thank you for signing up! Your request may take up to one week to be processed.
    see all newsletters