Lindsey Cascaddan Roberts Welcomes Daughter Georgia Jane

09/25/2015 at 01:15 PM ET

Survivor wasn’t the only big premiere this week.

Lindsey Cascaddan Roberts, a contestant on last season‘s Survivor: Worlds Apart, welcomed a daughter on Wednesday, Sept. 23, in Orlando, Florida, she confirms to PEOPLE exclusively.

Born at 1:48 a.m., Georgia Jane Roberts weighed in at 7 lbs., 14 oz., and measured 21 inches long. She joins older sister Eila Jane, 4.

Roberts, a lead hairstylist at a salon, was part of the “Blue Collar” tribe on last season’s Survivor. She married her longtime boyfriend Ryan Roberts after he returned from Afghanistan earlier this year. (He now works as a personal trainer and wellness coach.)

“Ryan and I have waited and worked at this — at us, at her — for more than 10 years,” Cascaddan Roberts, 25, tells PEOPLE.

Survivor's Lindsey Cascaddan Welcomes Daughter Georgia
Lindsey Cascaddan Roberts

Survivor's Lindsey Cascaddan Welcomes Daughter Georgia
Lindsey Cascaddan Roberts

The entire family is thrilled with their new addition.

“She’s so much more than we could have ever expected. She is what fairy tales are made of and how every great love story should end: with love and with so many new beginnings,” says the mom of two.

Survivor's Lindsey Cascaddan Welcomes Daughter Georgia
Lindsey Cascaddan Roberts

— Steve Helling

Share this story:

Your reaction:

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

Showing 6 comments

charlotte on

Sweet baby. Congrats.

Chelsie Smith on

Same middle name for siblings? Different.

Laura on

I know three siblings who all had the same middle name since the dad didn’t think it was right to name the son after himself.

Sara on

Myself and both my brother and sister have the same middle name. Its my paternal grandmothers maiden name. All three of my kids have my last name as their middle name.

Paula on

She is adorable! Congrats.

Anonymous on

Congrats to them, and fantastic name!