Dave and Odette Annable Welcome Daughter Charlie Mae – See Her First Photos!

09/10/2015 at 02:05 PM ET

Dave Odette Annable welcome daughter Charlie Mae
Michael Simon/StarTraks

Dave Annable‘s heart just skipped a beat: He’s a dad!

The Heartbreaker star and his wife Odette are first-time parents after welcoming a daughter on Monday, Sept. 7, they announced Thursday on social media.

“Odette and I couldn’t be happier to announce the arrival of the love of our lives. Welcome to the world Charlie Mae Annable,” Annable, 35, wrote alongside a photo of his baby girl gripping his finger on Instagram.

The new dad didn’t miss the irony of his daughter’s Labor Day arrival.

“Team Annable did not get the memo that ‘Labor Day’ wasn’t to be taken literally. Charlie is a holiday all on her own,” he added. “Mom and baby are in great health, and dad hasn’t stopped crying since. Shocker. Charlie is one lucky girl to have you as a mother @odetteannable. You are made from heaven.”

In her own announcement, The Astronaut Wives Club actress tweeted, “Dave and I are thrilled to introduce the newest member of the Annable family … Charlie Mae Annable. Born Sept. 7th.”

In May, the actor announced the pregnancy to his followers by wishing his wife both a happy birthday and congratulating her on her first Mother’s Day.

Although the couple didn’t know the sex of their baby on the way at the time, that didn’t stop the mom-to-be from splurging on a few baby items during their trip to Europe. And while Annable told PEOPLE it was “the most exciting time” of his life, the real surprise came when the two found out they would be welcoming a daughter.

“He just cried like a baby when he found out [it was a girl],” Odette told PEOPLE in July.

“Because it was a little girl, he was like, ‘Oh my God, what am I going to do?’ He’s so sensitive already, but it’s on overload.”

The couple spent the last few weeks before Charlie’s big debut finishing up their to-do lists, including the final touches on the nursery and assembling all the baby gear.

“This is full on nesting home. We’re trainwrecks — we’re hot messes — and then all of the sudden, it’s like ‘Oh, s—, we’re having a kid,’ ” he told PEOPLE. “We’re taking care of the house and putting the nursery together. I’ve been building all the cribs and the strollers. We feel fortunate enough to be married for five years — she’s sick of me so she’s ready for the next thing — but we’ve gotten to do it and live the life a little bit, so now we can’t wait to raise this little monkey.”

And other than dreaming of his daughter joining him for a game of golf one day, the future father was most looking forward to finally meeting his baby girl.

“The one piece of advice that has been a common denominator is just enjoy,” he said. “It goes by so quickly and just enjoy every second you’ve got with the kid. Life is precious, and that smile — I can’t wait to see that smile.”

On Tuesday, the shared a sneak peek at Charlie’s grin, introducing her in two Instagram photos — one on Mom’s account, and one on Dad’s.

My little Chicken Wing 🐣

A post shared by @ odetteannable on

— Anya Leon with reporting by Nicole Sands

Share this story:

Your reaction:

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.

Showing 12 comments

Gaby on

Aww congrats to Odette and Dave!

Jen on

Love the name Charlie for a girl. Congrats to them both!

Italy on

I just fell in love with her while watching the Astronaut Wives Club….that show was the BEST!!!
So happy for this sweet couple and their growing family…God Bless!!

K on

Curses! I wanted her name to be Annabel Annable. 😦 lol

Anonymous on

Love the name!!

Anonymous on

Congrats to them! A bit confused as to why they need more than one crib, though!

Red on

Maybe they have more than one house so they needed more than one crib? Or maybe one at a grandparents house? When I was a kid my grandma had a crib in her spare room for when she was babysitting grandkids.

Anonymous on

Red- Good points. My guess is that the extra cribs were for grandparents’ houses or perhaps for trailers, dressing rooms, or other set hangouts (since he referred to their house and nursery in the singular, I’m guessing they only have the one house). And honestly, I don’t know why I didn’t think of that myself!

Jayleen on

What a cutie–so precious!

Pam on

Oh my gosh she’s so cute! 😊

Anonymous on

I love the way he loves his wife and daughter 🙂

Maribel on

How precious are these three! They seem like such a sweet couple and will make great parents. I’m a mommy to a 6 month old now, I know how beautiful it is! Congrats!