Surrounded by 40 friends and family, the Dancing with the Stars champ and his girlfriend enjoyed cake from Sugar Fairy Bake Shop and “teared up” as they read messages guests had inscribed into a book. “It was lovely,” says stylist Jayneoni Moore, who helped to create the party’s theme.
“Our immediate families don’t live in L.A.,” Martinez, 28, tells PEOPLE. “We were worried about the love and support we would receive, but after the shower, Diana and I know we are surrounded by love and support on both coasts.”
|Jennifer Carrillo/Bella Rosa Photography|
Held at the home of All My Children executive producer Julie Hanann Carruthers, guests showered the couple — who met on the set of the former ABC soap — with gifts, including an Orbit Baby stroller and Daddy Scrubs.
The finishing touch? On their way out, each guest received a china teacup and saucer with English teas.
– Michele Stueven
For more exclusive photos and details on the special occasion, pick up the new issue of PEOPLE, on newsstands Friday.