Moms & Babies

Celebrity Baby Blog
Dec 09 2008 09:00 AM ET
Comments (33) Permalink

CBB Talks to The Office's Melora Hardin, Part 2

Frederick M. Brown/Getty

In the second part of our exclusive interview with The Office’s Melora Hardin, Danielle spoke at length with her abouther two homebirths, extended nursing and co-sleeping.

Click ‘More’ to read our exclusive interview! (Click here for part one of our interview.)

Frederick M. Brown/Getty

Danielle: I wanted to talk to you about attachment parenting. We’re passionate about it at CBB, and it’s great to hear a celebrity talking about it. Are you very open about it in your regular life?

Melora Hardin: I talk about it all the time with people. It’s the kind of thing that works very, very well with our family. It has to work well for the family — the mother, the father and the children. I think if it works well for the parents, it works for the children. I feel that it’s been the absolute perfect solution for our family. I think it creates children who feel very secure in the world, and we both really love that.

Both my husband and I know there’s going to be a day like, “What? What do you mean? In your bed? Yuck!” They don’t sleep in our bed anymore, they sleep together in their own beds, but they do come into our beds most nights, around five in the morning they end up in there and sleep the last few hours in bed with us. But they did both sleep in bed with us for about two years each.

I breastfeed both of them for two and a half years each. I feel like for me, I was not a sleep-deprived mother, because I got really comfortable with the idea of rolling over, plopping my boob in their mouth and they would go back to sleep and so would I. And that was easier for me than getting up out of bed and sitting in a chair next to the crib.

I never knew about attachment parenting at all, until I had my daughter. There weren’t many mainstream role models a few years ago.

I think it’s a great thing, and something people should feel confident and comfortable with, and not stressed out about. When I was doing it, I had so many people asking me, “When are you going to stop breastfeeding? When she’s 16?” Joking like that. And it’s like, “Well I’ll do it when it’s time to stop!”

In countries where they breastfeed at least a year and over a year, their rate of breast cancer is so much lower than this country. It’s what they’re meant to do. The plumbing needs to be used. It’s good for your boobs! And it’s great for the baby. And there’s still this culture within our culture that is very quiet about all this stuff, but luckily there are more and more people getting open to it. It just worked for me. I don’t judge other people doing that, I think it’d be great for people to have enough relaxation around it to make a decision based on what feels right for them and their baby.

When my kids were two-and-a-half and breastfeeding, that was just for snacks, for comfort. They weren’t breastfeeding in the daytime ever. It was just at night, a little bit, to help them sleep. We weaned down to a normal schedule, but it wasn’t pushed and rushed. I loved breastfeeding, I loved the whole experience. They were eating full meals from me until they were six to nine months old, then food, then as the food came, they just wanted me less and less. It was more about seeing mommy and having comfort, having cuddles. By the time they were 18 months old we stopped breastfeeding in public, by the time they were 2 years old, we cut out the snacks and were only doing night feedings. So I did what I felt was the right thing, based on my discomfort.

I kind of think of animals when it comes to this. Like when a cow doesn’t want their calf to nurse anymore, they kick them! When they’re done nursing them, they’ll walk away, go somewhere else, the calf will come, they’ll walk away again, the calf will come again, and they’ll kick them. And I felt a little bit like that! When I got frustrated with the amount of breastfeeding we were doing, I’d cut it down. I’d talk to them about it — even though they couldn’t understand. “We’re still going to have booby, but we’re not going to have it in public. We’re only going to have it at home.” So if we were out and they said they wanted booby, I’d say we’d have it at home. And they really got that — it wasn’t a hard transition for us. But I wasn’t trying to do it when they were five months old.

So I find it really great and really liberating and empowering, and I think it creates reasonable and confident children. My kids got a lot from it, I think.

They’re the most amazing travelers. I breastfed them on planes, and we never had screaming children, because they were just so content. When they’re feeling fussy or need to go to sleep or suck, you just put them on the boob and they’re happy.

Michael Williams/Startraks

Did you research this while you were pregnant? Were you breastfed? Did you have people around you practicing attachment parenting?

I started reading some books when I was pregnant with my first daughter, and I had two homebirths, so I was planning my homebirth and reading about different things, and I found the Dr. Sears book and that really helped me a lot.

Reading that book and hearing that they had seven or eight children but didn’t start attachment parenting til their last three was interesting. And he’s a pediatrician and she’s a nurse, and they talk about the difference between practicing attachment parenting with their last three and how that affected their last three as compared to their first five or so. I thought that was fascinating, from people with that kind of experience — really quite mainstream. I thought it was a pretty great testimonial for the method, and I talked to my husband about it, and he thought it sounded good and we thought we’d try it.

I remember when I started breastfeeding [my daughter] in bed I was afraid to move, and I spent a few nights being very uncomfortable — I didn’t want to move because I didn’t want her to be uncomfortable. But I realized that was ridiculous, and started moving her over, and putting her in a position where I could be comfortable. The amazing thing about babies is that they’ll do what you want them to do, if you help them through that without getting angry or frustrated.

In our house, even when an infant would wake up in the middle of the night for whatever reason, we never turned the lights on or made it time to wake up. Even if we knew we were going to be awake for an hour or two, it was all about going back to sleep. We’re sitting in the rocking chair, the lights are out, we’re laying on the bed, we’re under the covers, we’re rocking, we’re singing. Even if we had to turn music on or dance around, we kept the lights off. I feel like that helps let them know what’s expected of them, and you do it in the most loving way with the most patience that you can.

Were you and your husband breastfed?

My mom tried to breastfeed me. She told the doctor she was going to breastfeed me, and he said, “What are you, bovine?” She was incredibly embarrassed, needless to say. She had no support. She fed me for about six weeks, but says her milk dried up. I’m sure she had plenty of milk and could have been successful, but she didn’t know how to do it. She tried. With my older brother, she also tried, but when my brother was born, he was born in New York, in a progressive hospital where they allowed my father in the room, where that’s not traditionally done. I was born in Texas, where they didn’t let men in the room. My mom had to go through this labor all by herself, and she tells the story of a nurse coming in the room saying, “Can I get you anything?” And my mom said, “Yes, your hand!” And she says she remembers trying not to squeeze her hand too hard. It’s just so horrific to think that this is how it was done!

As that as a comparison to attachment parenting, there’s going to be a day where people go, “Can you believe there was a day when people didn’t do this?” If people can look beyond their own backyards, there are tons of cultures that have practiced “attachment parenting” since the beginning of time. They don’t have the luxury to be in five bedrooms and four-bathroom homes. They don’t have that. So they all sleep on the same mat, the same tent, the same dirt floor.

What was your husband’s experience like, growing up in England?

He wasn’t breastfed, and he was a C-section baby. He was a scheduled C-section — who knows whether his mom needed it or not — but pretty traditional, Victorian birth. Certainly not any of this attachment parenting!

It must’ve been dramatic for his family to hear about this then.

My mother-in-law, who is very English, when we had our first daughter and she heard she was sleeping in the bed with us, she said, “Well I told my friends there’s no sex in that house!” I couldn’t believe she said the word “sex” to me! And I said, “Oh don’t worry about that, we’re doing just fine.”

That’s another thing about attachment parenting that people worry about — they think if the kid is in the bed with you that you’re not having sex with your husband. And there are a lot of other places to have sex besides in the bed!

I have friends whose young daughter shared their bed for a few years and her friends said, “How can you have sex?” and she always said, “On the couch, on the floor, in the kitchen…”

Anyway, there are definitely a lot of misconceptions about sex, bonding time for the husband, not being able to go out when breastfeeding. I always wonder why they think it’s any of their business.

It should be everyone’s business — people should realize ignorance breeds prejudice. If you’re ignorant about it, you should get informed about it, by talking to people who are practicing it. Or practice it yourself and see how it feels to you. Read some books with real-life testimonials, like the Dr. Sears books.

All of us who are parents realize that there is no perfect way. It’s just as random as a love relationship with your partner — you’re just finding your way as you go. Our culture says, “No sex this way! No sex that way!” And then billboards are flashed everywhere about sex, too. So you have to remember we are a country built on Puritanical guidelines, and I think that’s something that never goes away. Yet we’re probably one of the most promiscuous cultures, all under the surface, with all these kinky things people do that they don’t want to reveal. I think the best thing is to talk about attachment parenting and what it’s really like.

People get really offended when we talk on the site about attachment parenting. We see that with a lot of parenting issues like vaccinations, circumcision. Do you see that?

I think people get threatened. They think you’re saying that they’re bad because they’re doing it differently than you’re doing it. I ran into that a lot with the homebirth situation. People love to tell their birth horror stories, and I didn’t have any horror stories. I had two beautiful births at home that I feel really great about, and I would always choose to do that at home unless I had to go to a hospital. I think hospitals are fantastic for emergency or high-risk situations. But luckily I didn’t have that. I think people take it personally, they feel threatened that you did something outside of their understanding, which isn’t different when it comes to a lot in our culture — why our races don’t understand each other and why in 2008 we still have racial issues. It’s why people of one religion think another is wrong.

We value right and wrong, black and white — we value extremes. We don’t value trying to sort of discover and experience and appreciate the other side of things … I don’t think you can preach to the choir, I think it’s dangerous to do that, and I don’t have interest in doing that. I don’t have interest in making people feel bad about what they’ve done because of what I’ve done. I feel really good about what I’m doing for my family. It’s working for us — we’re a happy little group. If someone wants to look at me and get inspiration from that, then great. But if they don’t, and they want to judge it and say they think my methods are crap, then that’s fine!

Comments (33) + Add a comment

Wow. she definatley has a different perspective on parenting than me – but it is so nice to hear what others are doing. Good for her for doing what works for her family and her little girls! Nice interview Danielle!

- D on

Awesome!!!
This woman rocks.Hopefully with more and more articles on homebirth and AP coming to the forefront we AP’ers won’t been seen as weird/strange/whacko so much.
I breastfeed my youngest son until age two and we were VERY discreet but the looks of disgust use to drive me insane!

- Natasha S on

I’m just glad to know that I’m not the only one who chose to breastfeed for so long. I nursed my daughter until she was 2 1/2.

- Jaime on

Wonderful job Danielle!!!Kudos to YOU and Melora. This would be great to see in Mothering Magazine.

- Aitch on

Natasha, I know what you mean. My youngest is 32 months, and still nursing. We have been asked in public, to not nurse, but to let employees know, so they can “tuck us away” in private. it infuriates me!
i have never read any AP books, it’s just always been the instinctive thing for me to do. i love co-sleeping, nursing, cloth… all of it. :) glad to see so much exposure for it here, danielle & co.!

- jaQ on

Thanks for this–she is a wonderful AP celebrity rolemodel.

- anne on

I had an unassisted home waterbirth last February, and I’m still nursing my 2 year old for comfort and for the health benefits. I am so glad to see a celebrity practicing attachment parenting and talking about it.

- Samantha B on

Yay! Excellent interview!
I breastfed my oldest four for between 11 months and 2.5 years, and will definantly be breastfeeding my twins when they arrive.
I also have had four homebirths. For the twins I will be in the hospital because it’s high risk, but that’s fine with me.
I love co-sleeping! No enough sex?! I have 6 kids in 6 years (very soon anyways!).
Way to go Melora! It’s great to see a celeb talking about all this.

- Jazz on

I just love how open and honest and accepting Melora is–many times you don’t get that with the way a person has chosen to parent.
Personally, I stayed at home as long as I could before getting to the hospital, tried but lacked enough supply to breastfeed, and moved my son to his own room because he seems to sleep better that way. But I certainly don’t judge anyone by the way they decide to raise their children; aren’t we all just muddling through this anyway?

- Jen on

P.S.–Can I just say I love that one of her daughters has an African American baby doll? I always did when I was growing up (I’m white) and always got the strangest looks, but my family never thought it was weird!

- Jen on

I love her honestly & openness to talk about her experiences; good or bad. I think she is truly a wonderful role model for many people!

- Lori on

Wow, love her. She’d fit in fabulously with my group of friends. Almost all co-sleep, extended breastfeed, and many of us have had homebirths. And when we’re in the mainstream, other mothers talk to us like we’re child abusers. Thank you, Melora, for putting a famous face on a different, wonderful method of parenting.

- Ann E. Mouse on

I’m due in 9 weeks and trying to read books on various parenting methods. My husband’s cousin gave me Babywise but I’m also interested in AP. I figure theories on parenting are great but I don’t yet know what will work for my husband, our baby, and myself so I want to learn about everything so we can make the most informed decision. I wish Melora had said which Dr. Sears’ books she’d read.

Does anyone have an AP book to recommend to me?

All in all, a very nice article I think!

- MB on

Three words: I LOVE HER!

Way to be so honest and real about AP. Thank you for this perspective. I wish all babies could be birthed naturally, at home, and breastfed until they are ready to wean. Our world would be a much nicer place.

- yogadaisy on

Melora Hardin is fantastic–great interview!

We parent the same way: homebirthing, breastfeeding, wearing our baby, co-sleeping…
I never set out to follow any “method,” but just parented by instinct. It just made sense to feed the baby when she was hungry, or have her sleep next to me instead of leaving her to cry in another room. I think listening to your heart–and your baby–is the best way to parent, regardless of method.

- joy on

great article.

MB: dr. sears has a book called “attachment parenting” i think. all of his books, though, underscore this method. and while i’m not a full-on attachment parent (we do NOT co-sleep) i love all his books. i would really be wary of babywise, though, especially if attachment parenting sounds appealing to you. it’s generally not conducive to establishing a good milk supply, should you breastfeed. i’m not trying to start any arguments, i’m just saying. good luck!

- marla on

Awesome! It’s refreshing to see someone who has found a wonderful way to raise her two chidlren regardless of what our society has to say. She ROCKS!!!!

- Mickey on

I love her! I tend to be more mainstream myself, but agree with and parent by the attachment parent philosophy. I am glad this is starting to get more mainstream!

To a PP, Dr. Sear’s The Baby Book is a great resource. He has a chapter about AP, but also talks about milestones, illnesses, baby care. It is a great encyclopedia for new mothers!

- JJS on

I love that she’s so non-judgemental about the way she parents! I think it’s great when you find something you like for your family, she’s right it is all just trial and error, over and over. Everyone tries thier best. I take some stuff AP adivce and some from other areas. You don’t have to be slave to one method at all.

- Rebecca on

I totally agree with breastfeeding as long as the child needs it. My daughter was 20 months old when she stopped. As was the case with my daughter, for my son, I stopped offering at 18 months but never denied the request. After 3 weeks not nursing and into the 21st month, he was impatient. When the milk wasn’t there “instantly”, he slapped my breast softly, looked me in the eye and said, “Mommy, it’s broken.” :) Breastfeeding was definitely one of the most rewarding experiences of my life – both for my children, and in hindsight, knowing the benefits since my mother passed away from breast cancer 2 years ago and only breastfed me for a short time in the ’60′s because her mother felt “only poor people do that.” So happy that times have changed!

- Eileen Sturge on

I totally respect her choices and I especially respect how educated she seems to be about them. They’re all things I’d consider if I had kids.

But I’m curious about the etymology phrase “attachment parenting”. Without knowing about the roots behind it, I find it a little questionable. My cousin, for example, was unable to breastfeed and did not choose to sleep in the same bed as her child. Does this make her a detached parent?

I’m not trying to start anything, just curious as to what’s behind it. Physical attachment does not encompass all attachment.

- Chiara on

thank you for this article! thank you to melora hardin for sharing her experiences. my husband and i practice attachment parenting and have a firm belief that it helps to develop a very secure, confident child. we always get comments from others of how we need our privacy, that we shouldn’t let our children sleep in our bed, how do we get our sleep, etc.. etc… we used to explain but now, it’s what worked for our family when our son was born and is continuing to work for our family with our daughter. we both feel a close bond to our children and wouldn’t change anything about how we are parenting today.

- rij on

Excellent interview, and good on CBB for promoting AP!

- SM on

Chiara, from what I understand (and I could be wrong), attachment parenting came from a psychological theory about babies feeling detached from the mother because of the birthing process (no longer being in the womb). It is not supposed to insinuate that parents who don’t use this method aren’t attached emotionally to their kids.

Maria, thanks for the info/advice! I do plan on breastfeeding, for as long as I possibly can (at least 6 months exclusively). I did wonder about my milk supply under Babywise.

CBB: I’d love to see a “sound-off” on different parenting styles. I know that there is the potential for a heated discussion, but it would be such a great way for those of us expecting moms or future moms to hear from other moms about what has worked for them and their families.

- MB on

Wow, excellent article, it’s so refreshing to finally see someone who shares AP experiences similar to that of my own family in such a positive light on such a mainstream blog.

I think everyone thinks that what they’re doing is what’s best for their child and situation, but I do think that people need to really educate themselves as much as possible so that they do make informed decisions, and not be judgemental about how others parent their own children.

- MZ on

As an reader in England i’m offended at her negative generalisations of the English people. Attachment parenting is big over here and lots of people breastfeed and have done for years (my parent were and so was i), we’re not unfeeling, traditional and cold as she seems to suggest. making generalisations and using terms like “traditional, Victorian birth” and referring to his mother in law as “very English” and then saying she is critical rub me up the wrong way, its like she’s equating being english with being non modern and unsupportive. If here mother in law is non supportive its becasue of her as a person- not that she is English. As for “victorian” birth- how old is her husband anyway? Queen Victorias reign ended with her death in 1901!

- K on

Wow, I agree with everything this woman said!! And for a celebrity that’s VERY rare for me.

My mother had the same experience as her mother: alone when giving birth (this was in the 1970s and 80s) because fathers were not allowed in the birth room, no support with breastfeeding from doctors, etc., but luckily my grandmothers lived the AP method (out of necessity, since my parents were born after WWII in SE Europe, both had homebirths because there was no way to get to the hospital in time, breastfed their kids because there was no money to buy baby food, had one room where the whole family slept, etc.).

When I have kids I plan to breastfeed, co-sleep, etc. My only regret is that I wont be able to have homebirths because they’re illegal hare (hopefully that might change in the next few years).

I find it funny and ironic, how America is discovering things that are considered normal, boring and expected here and then have the gall to call us ‘backward’.

- Sanja on

I don’t comment here much anymore but this woman is AWESOME!

- amelita on

I LOVE this interview! Thank you for posting it!

As an attachment parent myself, it’s nice to read about celebrities who do it, too.

Homebirth… co-sleeping… extended breastfeeding… way to go Melora! (And thank you CBB for putting AP into the spotlight.)

- Stephanie on

Sanja,

Not all Americans have the same feelings/opinions towards different cultures; not even close. Honestly, Melora’s beliefs (which I agree with wholeheartedly) are not ridiculously far out of the mainstream here. Even for those who disagree with the methods of other cultures I think it would be hard to find anyone willing to openly label them “backwards.”

IMO, the idea of the closeminded American is a huge stereotype.

- Erica on

What a wonderful interview! It’s great to see AP highlighted in this way. We planned to AP except for the co-sleeping, but once my daughter was born we realized that co-sleeping was just another wonderful aspect of AP that we loved, AND it meant more sleep for all of us!

Thank you for this interview – and I second the comment that this should be in Mothering magazine!

- heidi on

She’s gorgeous and her girls are beautiful.

- terri on

Hey, I can’t seem to access part one of this awesome interview?

- Margo on

Advertisement

Add A Comment

PEOPLE.com reserves the right to remove comments at their discretion.




Get Moms & Babies Everywhere

Advertisement

Squeals & Deals

Sign-up for the Mom's &s Babies Free Weekly Newsletter

Free Weekly Newsletter

Mom Said It

"Now our kids are friends too and as they grow, it will be wonderful to watch them all and the different stages in their lives."

 

From Our Partners