Preesi,

Heather and Denise were never best friends. They lived in the same neighborhhod and were celebrities. We saw them together, with other friends, a total of one time. I’m not getting into what transpired between them, but calling them best friends is more than a stretch.

I personally would live a house full of little girls, but wouldn’t love a son any less.

I really hope that Brooke will opt out of this relationship and has children of whatever gender with someone other than Charlie. That will save her a lot disappointments later in life.

Tracey,

Obviously, you are not a fan of Brooke’s. And I do not know any of these people personally, of course. However, you do not need to jump all over me and other people on this board who are merely commenting on the situation.

I have no idea (neither do you) what goes on behind closed doors in their home. I have no doubt, however, that Charlie and Denise as well as Brooke love and care for these girls very much, and my wish is they behave like adults for the sake of these children.

Of course, now we know that you are posting under two different names, so it is my assumption that you are here merely to stir things up.

I don’t know what others may think is the reason for the donation request but POSSIBLY it could be that she wants ALL her children to be biologically the same: 50% her 50% him. Also, I never heard WHEN this request was actually MADE (not reported) so that may be telling. I don’t know…. that’s the only logical reason I could figure.?.

Regarding the donation- Why on Earth would Denise want to have another kid with Charlie (nothing against Charlie, mind you. I just don’t understand why Denise would have a desire to have another child with her ex)??????

Goodness, such debate over these people!

I really don’t like any of them TBH. Just something about everyone in the situation bugs me.

The girls really are adorable, though, and I hope that every child any of them have can lead a normal life with everything that has come up/they have been put through.

And my mother ALWAYS said she wanted a boy, she had 3 girls and my first was a girl. She told me she would be extremely upset if I didn’t have a boy first. But my daughter came and she couldn’t love her more, and neither could I. (I personally wanted a girl first since my entire family is made up of girls. That and the clothes are cuter lol)

But I now have a son also. What bothers me is everyone always says to me, “Now you have your pair!” or “How wonderful, you have one of each!” I always have wanted one of each but I feel like saying, “And what if I had another girl? Would we not have a wonderful pair then?”

I just feel sorry for the CHILDREN. If the adults want to go at each other I just wish they’d do it in private. Showing donation requests, giving interviews, etc. on any side is lousy for the children. It seems like not in the all to distant past there was collective sigh of relief regarding these adults. Come on Charlie/Brooke/Denise… we are rooting for you all so those darling babes will have a loving childhood!

preesi, no need to scream at me!! I hadn’t heard about showing the document to whomever he showed it to. I still don’t think it is any of our business. I like coming here to admire celebrity babies…not discuss very personal parts of their lives which I care nothing about or pick apart their parenting or car seat usage. I think things have gotten waaay out of hand around here again.

Sarah’s note: I agree. Discussion please, not arguing. Or this will be another one we have to close comments on. Thanks.

Tink? Charlie showed the Donation Request to Entertainment Tonight and it was verified, so it did indeed happen.
http://www.etonline.com/celebrities/news/49309/index.html
Watch Mark Steines say that he did indeed SEE the written request for a DONATION!

I honestly think that whole “donation” thing was a rumor. I don’t believe it for one second. As for Denise and Heather and the whole Richie Sambora thing…Heather and Richie were over long before Denise and he got together. It wasn’t as if she stole him away from Heather. I think its a little tacky that they dated, but to each his own. Heather seems to have moved on just fine and isn’t letting any of it bother her and never did. As for why did Denise divorce Charlie??? There were allegations of abuse and his cheating and also drugs involved on Charlie’s part. Nobody knows but them and we shouldn’t really speculate. Denise seems to be a very good mother and that is what really matters.